• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Storied Mind

Recover Life from Depression

  • Home
  • About
    • Commenting Guidelines
  • START HERE
    • Archives
  • Self-Help
    • Recovery Stories
You are here: Home / Healing / Brain and Consciousness: Jill Bolte Taylor

Brain and Consciousness: Jill Bolte Taylor

by John Folk-Williams 1 Comment

Please note that this post has been revised to reflect commentary on Jill Bolte Taylor’s reliance on the right brain—left brain model. See the note at the end of this post.

If you have any interest at all in the relationship between the brain and your awareness of who you are, please go straight to this site. Read the excerpt from Jill Bolte Taylor’s book, My Stroke of Insight: A Brain Scientist’s Personal Journey. Then listen to the podcast of Terry Gross’s interview with the author on Fresh Air. I heard it this morning on the radio, and it’s provided more insight about the human power to heal than all the books and articles I’ve read to date.

Here is the case of a neuroscientist felled by a stroke that wiped out the functionality of the left¹ side of her brain, the center of the faculties for language, analysis, speech. The stroke removed memories of her life, though she knew the information was there – the ability to access it was gone. She couldn’t speak or understand or read words. In many ways, she had become infantile, and with the help of her amazing mother learned all over again how to speak, use language, codify the world.

But the right¹ side of her brain remained untouched, fully functional. That is the center of intuition, associational thinking, the ability of the conscious mind to grasp the whole and to envision reality. Strangely, after her stroke, she felt a powerful euphoria, and that awareness of the state of near spiritual intensity never left her. So during a years-long and difficult recovery, she felt remarkably upbeat and happy, even when she had only a few minutes of energy during the day. Living primarily through right brain experience completely changed her sense of who she was.

As she relearned language and restudied the technical subjects she had mastered before her stroke, she says that she always kept in mind the pictures, diagrams, images that she still remembered and associated with those subjects, even though the words and concepts had disappeared. Slowly she regained the abilities to use abstract reasoning, retain knowledge gained through words, speak and analyze.

With those mental processes functioning again, however, she also found returning a level of tension, anxiety, nervousness and other forms of stress that had once been an all too common part of her life. Now, though, with her strong intuitive abilities and awareness of a different way of experiencing life, she is quick to say: Stop! and to pull back from purely analytical thinking. She finds the balance and rich inner life she depends on by paying more attention to her intuitive self than to her analytic powers.

Though not religious, she has come to appreciate how common among humanity are the spiritual experiences very like the intense euphoria and inner awakening that has been a rich part of her intuitive life since the stroke. She thinks of the world’s religions as the stories people tell to explain the depth and power of these extraordinary moments when a person is lifted out of the realm of the everyday.

These are just a few ideas that struck me in listening to the interview this morning. Hear for yourself, read what she has to say, and let me know if this connects with your experience as deeply as it does with mine.

Note – 7/28/08

¹ Throughout her book and presentations, Taylor relies on the right brain—left brain model to explain the locations of the two sets of faculties that she identifies with two separate voices or personalities within her mind. The use of this model has come under fire from several observers because it is considered an out-of-date depiction of the brain. Current ideas of the location of the specific functions she mentions indicate they are not confined so completely to one hemisphere or the other. See, for example, Chauncey Bell, Dangerous Intersection and a post summarizing such reactions at Idealawg.

It’s also important to read the comments on these posts since several of those criticize two of the writers for missing the point of Taylor’s experience. They point out, and I agree, that the essence of her presentations is not the location of mental faculties in the brain but rather the nature of the inner experience she records.

Image: Some rights reserved by DerrickT at Flickr

Related Posts

  • Oneness, Depression & Jill Bolte Taylor

    The story of her stroke and remarkable recovery are now well-known, through her book, My…

  • The Divided Brain

    With the aid of rapid-fire animation, this video on the divided brain illustrates part of…

  • healing through the emotional brain
    Healing Depression through the Emotional Brain

    I've tried many methods for treating my own depression over the years but have most…

Filed Under: Healing, Spirituality Tagged With: brain, religion

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. don salmon says

    January 3, 2017 at 9:02 am

    Hi Derrick [John]:

    I’ve been following the “left brain right brain” controversy for a long time, and I thought you did a particularly good job in your note at the end of presenting a balanced view of it.

    So many critics get caught up in the purely neurological critique. In fact, even on that score, neuroscientists are not nearly as clear about the validity or lack of validity of the right/left brain hypothesis. But assuming for the moment the location of mental faculties in the brain is completely different from what Taylor and others have said.

    The fact remains, that neuroscientists are often woefully unqualified to make an adequate critique of the psychological distinctions that Taylor, McGilchrist and others are making.

    I recently saw an excellent description by neuroscientist/meditation instructor John Yates of selective attention (mediated in part by the left hemisphere, but the right hemisphere is very much involved also) and peripheral awareness (mediated more primarily by the right hemisphere) which tracks the descriptions of Taylor and McGilchrist. Even if Yates is wrong and attention and awareness are actually mediated by the left foot and the right foot (!!), the psychological aspects are still completely in line with what all the other researchers have described – and, perhaps more important to many – in line with what contemplatives and meditators throughout the world have observed for several thousand years.

    Thanks for this post, it was very helpful.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Sign Up for Email Delivery

Get updates and blog posts by email.

Surviving Depression Together Now Available at Major Retailers

Surviving Depression Together


Surviving Depression Together

"John, this is a ... much needed resource. Thanks for writing it!"

- Therese Borchard, author of Beyond Blue


Learn More...

A Mind for Life Ebook Now Available at Major Retailers

A Mind for Life: From Depression to Living Well

A Mind for Life Ebook

The inner work of getting your life back from depression. This ebook is now available in most common ebook formats at major retailers.

LEARN MORE

Living Depressed

Depression affects emotions, mental abilities, self-concept, behavior, relationships and the entire body. These core posts describe the full range of symptoms affecting daily life. Read More.

Choices in Healing

Hoping for recovery gives you a motive but not a method for getting there. This section has posts about therapies and healing methods you can work with either on your own or with professional guidance. Read more.

Living Well

If you've learned how to manage your depression, you'll want a fulfilling life rather than one dominated by fear that the illness might return. In this section, you'll find posts about how to work toward that goal. Read More

Relationships in Crisis

One of the hardest challenges of living with depression is holding onto your closest relationships. This section features posts on how to help a relationship survive. Read More.

Recent Posts

  • Storied Mind Ebooks Ready to Go!
  • Notebook: Healing the Whole Person
  • Why Writing Helps Heal Depression – 2
  • Why Writing Can Help Heal Depression – 1
  • Re-Reading the Story of Depression’s Meaning

Search Storied Mind

Categories

Recent Comments

  • Linda on Helen: A Great Film on Depression
  • Anonymous on 10 Ways to Help Yourself When Your Partner Is Depressed
  • Karthika on How Can You Communicate After Your Depressed Partner Leaves?
  • Adam on How Can You Communicate After Your Depressed Partner Leaves?
  • Karthika on How Can You Communicate After Your Depressed Partner Leaves?
  • Adam on How Can You Communicate After Your Depressed Partner Leaves?
  • Anonymous on How Can You Communicate After Your Depressed Partner Leaves?
  • Karthika on How Can You Communicate After Your Depressed Partner Leaves?

Privacy and Cookie Policy

Privacy Policy

Cookie Policy

Terms of Use

DISCLAIMER: None of the content on this site should be interpreted as medical or therapeutic advice about the treatment of depression or any mental illness. If you feel you need help, you should seek treatment from qualified professionals.

AFFILIATES: We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Copyright © 2023 · Dynamik-Gen on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in