Making Decisions When Depressed


Like so many, I experience depression in various forms, yet each in its own way knocks out the decision control center in my mind. At times, I scramble in anxiety and can’t focus enough to pick out one among many possibilities. At other times, I don’t care about choosing – or anything else for that matter – and I let the alternatives fall where they may. Or I make all kinds of decisions, even life changing ones, but none of them seems like a choice. Each one is do-or-die. If I fail to do it, I’ll go right over the edge.

Varieties of Indecision

Depression isn’t one thing but a series of moods along a continuum from mild to severe. I used to move regularly with this perverse flow toward desperation. At the mild end, I might wake up knowing that something is wrong, feeling at once that everything is a bit off. I want and need to get a lot done, but I’ve lost my sense of where to begin and what’s most important. Then I get anxious.

There’s a steady snowfall of tasks, floating free of deadlines and priorities. I feel the anxiety and tension about getting them all done, so I pick one out of the air – yes, I’ve got to do that! Then I realize after a few minutes of continuing worry that I’ve got to do that other one in a hurry too. So I grab that and start working. And then another and another. It’s like picking snow flakes out of the air, each melting at once, a drop of moisture in my hand. I’ve got to get everything done, but I’m going crazy because I can’t grab hold of anything.

Then there are those times when I’ve felt nothing and could care less about making decisions. That’s happened most often when I’ve been on the antidepressants targeting serotonin, like Prozac. I think I’m fine because I don’t feel depressed, but then everything else, including close relationships, seemed far away and empty. I could drop them in a minute, and that might well seem to be the logical thing to do. The thinking brain can still function but cut loose from any tie to feeling. Decisions based on logic and indifference can be the most dangerous of all.

But on the other end of the spectrum, where major depression waits, there is plenty of feeling, but it’s all desperation. My survival is at stake. I have to be alone and shut the door on everyone I know. I have to quit this job, or it’ll destroy my life. Seeing this therapist makes me sicker, and I’ll go off the deep end if I don’t quit. This relationship is a trap that’s ruining my life. There are only relentless drives here, and everything I do or desperately feel I need to do simply has to happen. I have no power of choice. It’s easy to argue that a decision has been made. But I can’t see it that way, any more than I would say that someone under torture makes a choice to confess and stop the unbearable pain.

What Does It Take to Decide?

The psychologist James Hillman wrote a book called Kinds of Power in which he presents an interesting take on decisions. This may sound a bit pedantic, but he looks at the root meanings of the word from a Latin verb meaning to cut or to kill. Decision/decide shares this root with words like incision and homicide. Cutting away or killing off are useful metaphors because that’s what I have to do to pick one among many possibilities.

Cut away the extraneous possibilities and narrow down to specific action that will accomplish something: here’s what to do, now do it. Choices must be made to keep life and mind moving. But to do that, I need a clear vision of what I want, confidence that I can do it and belief that I can improve my life by acting in this way. When depressed, those are exactly the qualities I know I don’t have.

Depression brings the whole world inside me. I look at people and everything around me, and I’m not seeing anything but evidence of how bad I am. I’m dancing with my own nightmares. Even if I’m only mildly depressed and feel suspended amid a thousand possibilities, no one of which I can choose, I’m assuming that whichever I might pick will not take me anywhere. I’ll move in an endless circle.

Or else I’ll feel nothing, and there is no point in wanting anything. I put on a good show, pass for happily adjusted to life but only see blankness ahead – if I take the trouble to look. And in the most desperate state of severe depression, I’m running for my life. The idea of choosing a different path doesn’t enter my mind.

What’s common to all those ways of being depressed is an all-or-nothing thinking. Nothing good can result from what I do, and so there is no vision that I can choose of my own will. Everyone else is better than I am, and each seems a powerful presence that only makes me smaller still. Whatever I do will not work and only confirms the worst. All the creative possibilities I might see when I’m healthy become so many triggers of obsessive thinking.

When I began to recover some years ago, I started with a single decision. I can’t explain how it happened when I was so close to believing that I should do the world a favor and just disappear. But something snapped. All I could hear in my mind, louder than any sound I knew, was NO, I won’t go there, and YES, I’m getting out of this. I will do it. It was more than a survival instinct, or fear of where I was headed. I had to push hard against the current that was forcing me in the wrong direction, and suddenly the strength and purpose were there. I felt in my bones that I did have a choice, and I’d better make the right one.

Most people don’t have to make a decision like that. They can take self-respect for granted and get on with living. I guess people with severe depression have to work harder to master the most basic dimensions of life, to keep going and to kill of the impulse to stop.

How are you doing at deciding things these days?

Image: Some Rights Reserved by AMagill at Flickr

85 Responses to “Making Decisions When Depressed”

Read below or add a comment...

  1. Kayla says:

    Whenever it comes to deciding I usually choose “I don’t know.” And I try to go on from there. Often times I really don’t know what to choose. Especially if it’s something small, like choosing to eat between two of my favorite restaurants. Part of my indecisiveness has to do with “having a time limit.” I often feel the need to hurry up and choose, but in the end I panic, and in said situation, I choose not to eat overall. Though, generically I end up choosing whatever because I get sick and tired of thinking logically.

  2. Martha says:

    I need help and do not even know how to get help anymore.

  3. Tim says:

    My belief is that single decision to try and escape the paralysis of depression comes out of anger. Anger is the original feeling and depression is that anger suppressed. Anger is dangerous, destructive and highly risky which is why people try and control it. However if that control leads to something at least as bad – depression – then relearning how to express a bit of anger might be helpful, energising and able to lead to that decision to escape depression. This is true in my case. I suffer from chronic depression and have done since I was an adolescent at least. I find that acting on the anger that underlies my depression has been a much more rewarding strategy than trying to be rational and sensible and not take risks with the anger driven motivation to anything to escape depression.

  4. Sarah says:

    Thank you so much for this. I don’t use the words loosely, so I mean it when I say the words have really ‘driven-home.’ I have had depression for most of my life; since I was six-years-old. I have recently gone-through a break-up with the love of my life. We had been together for over 10 years, no kids, but realised later that he had been controlling me through a series of manipulations. I am now trying to get my life on-track, but it is so difficult. My depression in the past year has been the worst it has ever been. The two sentences that hit home for me, were, “Cut away the extraneous possibilities and narrow down to specific action that will accomplish something: here’s what to do, now do it. Choices must be made to keep life and mind moving.” and “All I could hear in my mind, louder than any sound I knew, was NO, I won’t go there, and YES, I’m getting out of this. I will do it. It was more than a survival instinct, or fear of where I was headed. I had to push hard against the current that was forcing me in the wrong direction, and suddenly the strength and purpose were there. I felt in my bones that I did have a choice, and I’d better make the right one.” Those are the two fundamental things those with depression have to keep with them. More than anything. To live a clear, progressive Life. There is only one way. No alternatives. No backing-down. And there is no way that anyone else is controlling my Life. I’m not living or leading my Life for anybody else. Time to get on it.

  5. Mika says:

    Wow this is so good. Thank you for sharing your experience. No one has explained to me that indecision is tied to depression- not articulated this well, anyway! This is me. I feel like I can hardly move because every little decision seems daunting. I feel crazy because no one, not even my doctor has been able to help me navigate and explain the level of dysfunction I feel everyday. This gives me hope. Thank you.

    • Anonymous says:

      Thank YOU Mika for sharing your feelings. I feel this SO much, “I feel like I can hardly move because every little decision seems daunting.” This paralysis of avoiding things, especially work related things that is just so hard to break through. It’s so hard to describe to anyone who doesn’t go through this. It’s so hard to fathom why simple decisions are just so hard, near impossible to overcome.

      But we’re working through it. Whew.

  6. Alla13 says:

    I write on occasion. I never write when Im depressed. I can never put sentences together when I feel like this. But I never felt as I do now. This is a new low for me. So I wrote:

    I pray for death, I can not fight.
    No more……
    No strength, no hop on the horizon.
    With years I haven’t gotten wiser.
    I cry, with reason and without.
    It’s pain….
    That’s what it’s all about.
    I live….For what?
    For mere existence.
    The chase, the game, the rush.
    The numbness sounds so appealing.
    Eternal peace?
    Well, that’s a feeling.
    The beauty of this world has dissipated.
    The future of my soul has slowly faded.
    I can’t find reasons to hold on.
    To pain? To suffering?
    The laughter, smiles…All have gone.
    The drugs no longer do their job.
    I’m scared of nights, I’m scared of light.
    My thoughts are poison to my heart.
    The loneliness is all I’ve got.
    My friend, my only confidant.
    The chaos is engulfing me.
    The life I dreamed is just a dream.
    The sun, the moon, the stars.
    And darkness………..

  7. Sean says:

    I’ve struggled with depression before I even knew what depression was. I was a happy person, but over the years, that happiness world became a globe of darkness, despair and a lack of purpose. I have acquired several degrees, and still no success. I’ve worked myself into the grave, attempting to make achieve any form of success, but nothing has paid off. All of those years were in vain.
    Walking day to day in this cloud, I’ve seen I have no control over anything. Every choice or path I’ve made or taken, has led to the same result, failure. No life changing results. Blessings, like magic, come with a price. They’ve always turned out to be blursings(blessings that turn out to be curses).I was having a “good” period where I felt like things were really changing, the veil had been lifted, but then just as soon as the sunlight seemed to be breaking through, the darkness grabbed me back down into pit, consuming all the light.
    I’ve been to doctors, taken pills, you name it, still no hope. This life would be much better served in death.

    • Id says:

      Please don’t give up. There will be light at the end of the tunnel. 🙂

      • P says:

        If you have degrees, you could would surely get satisfaction onehundredfold in knowing that your lessons will have positively influenced your pupils? This does happen, I taught 20 years ago and ex pupils still stop me to thank me. ????

  8. Julian says:

    I used to be very decisive and now being undeceive and second-guessing myself is a change. I’m getting better but still have a ways to go. This article helped me a lot. And I loved his description and his challenging ideas.

  9. satpal says:

    I have just completed my schooling I am thinking from last 2 month what should i do, now i am unable to decide what should i do. All options are looking tough down the line. Can you please help me out.

  10. Arooj says:

    Hello, my name is Arooj. ‘Making Decision when Depressed’ sound so much like me at the moment. i have to take a decision but i happened to cant take one. I dont know what i want. Due to my past failures and bad decisions i am unable to take any decision now.
    i have been moving alot in life from one country to another. it created problems for my studies. I took bad decisions. Till o levels I did fairly well though at that time i was quite unhappy with my results. But after that my life became full of bad decisions. i always wanted to do something in Maths. because i have always enjoyed solving problems in maths. But in my A levels Maths i ended up with a bad grade. i lost hope in maths and chose a different career that i never thought I would do it. i failed the first year of it. and now i am here in the same situation want to do something different again and this time it involves maths . but i am too scared to take that step because of the uncertainty

  11. Kevin says:

    This article and the one about depression in the workplace hit home hard. I’m a registered nurse who only has an associate’s degree, doing a job that I’m told I’m lucky to have since they couldn’t find anyone with a bachelor’s degree to work with Core Measures. I ran to this job drone floor nursing because I felt dread at being a floor nurse, and having an abusive manager who kept us after our shift to scold us for the most minor things,(ie recording a blood sugar in a different part of the health record than was desired) and keep us there for hours even though we had to work the next day! This core measures job unbeknownst to me has had several people quit due to another abusers manager who has no problem calling you worthless and screaming at you I front of everyone. I can’t seem to relax even when I get home as I continue to get nasty emails well after my workday is done! I compulsively have to check the or I can’t relax, but I often find myself wishing I would have not checked to begin with. I made a career decision to become a nurse because it was always pounded in my head to pick a career that was steady and always in need….this was when he was sober….I never knew if I was going to get beats or congratulated about something. I have been depressed even before I knew what that meant. I have a habit of life having to extracte me out of situations I’ve been in for way too long! It’s not that I don’t thing about planning, I just start thinking of making changes in my life like a career change, then I start looking for other careers, then a few minutes later I panic and start looking on the Internet for hobbiessince I don’t have any hobbies….then an few minutes later in another panic imagine myself being stuck where I am…then I start pacing. After that I start crying , then repeat that cycle until I fall asleep, then often I wake up and start again, but this time with a great deal of guilt from wasting my time from spinning my wheels! I carry guilt that we live in a house my mother in law owns and we pay no rent, but we still manage to have a bunch of debt. This thought races through my head and then I feel guilty for not getting my wife and kid out of this god forsaken town where we have no ties but the fear of leaving a free house which is falling apart! I am almost 47 and I have never owned anything worth more than a few thousand dollars as the thought of loosing it starts the mad cycle all over again! I cry every morning and I stay up late so it doesn’t seem like the night speeds buy like it does while you’re sleeping! Rinse and repeat! I started to take step like getting HR invoked at work and seeing a counselor after years of stigma, and I have tried to pray but then I feel guilty that I only seem to talk to God when I’m in trouble and need something….I am a hot mess and I need some help and advice!

    • Janette says:

      Hi Kevin.
      What an honest open account of how life is getting on top of you. Your clear description of where things are getting to you are a great start to getting better I think.
      Yep making decisions is really hard, but maybe instead of looking at so many issues at once, just accept life is all over the place and take tiny steps towards one thing you can change. Massive changes are really overwhelming. I get completely frozen with decision making when I have really high expectations of what I need to get done. If things are awful you always have a simple choice to make…You can accept the awful situation, and just get on with life..thinking things like”Ok. So I’m stuck right now in a house I hate can’t change that so will not worry about it any more” or you can refuse to accept it and take tiny steps to fix it. …Secret here is tiny…one tiny thing is much less overwhelming. Even just writing out possible tiny steps.
      I have an interesting analogy for how to make a decision that Wayne Dyer once told.
      If you need to walk into a theatre and sit down to watch a movie, you just automatically know how to do it. You walk towards your seat, no hesitation no second guessing and you sit.
      You don’t um and ahh.. you don’t wonder which is the best way you just know and you trust yourself. Well, that’s how I try approach all decisions that are bugging me. Just go there. Don’t second guess yourself. This helps alot when there’s a clear decision to be made.
      When you have heaps of decisions to make its awful. I now choor only one or two per day. ( of the major worries) to work on, I do a bit of work on it then get back to living…exercise, housework…kids etc. Otherwise I’d fo NOTHING, of either.
      I hope you’re feeling better Kevin. My heart goes out to you.

    • patrick says:

      you described exactly how i feel and the way my life is .my girlfriend gets mad and says its a pity thing stop feel sorry for yourself so i just seclude myself and it starts a fight because i ignore her

  12. Elizabeth says:

    Please can you give me some advice. I’m currently suffering with anxiety and depression over a choice I HAVE to make, not necessarily right now but in the near future. I’m from England and my boyfriend lives in Mexico, the decision I have to make is whether to leave my family and friends for a life in Mexico or finish with my boyfriend, who I love very much. It would be difficult for him to move to England because he would struggle to find work. This is the hardest decision I’ve ever had to make in my life and either option causes me anxiety. I’m so lost, I just don’t know what to do. I know I don’t need to decide right now but I feel like I can’t relax and I’m scared of making the wrong decision. Please help.

    • Ann says:

      Hi Elizabeth
      When in love you feel like leaving everything else and just choose love. Sounds a bit old fashioned but true.
      You boyfriend could be a very nice person but always think what is right for you England or Mexico. What about your family like parents brothers or sisters? Do they live in England? If yes take their help.
      Always remember if something happens in Mexico will you be able to cope with that and stand up on your feet?
      If yes and you are a strong woman go for it.

  13. Christine says:

    Oh my god. I actually feel like I could have written this, word for word. Minus the recovery part since I’m not there yet… But everything else, every other word. Wow. I can’t even make a decision to go away this weekend with friends! It’s so stupid. I’m a freelance writer with a big deadline for my book and I have interviews this weekend which I could technically do while I’m away (as long as I have Internet) but will I? Plus there’s the uncertain finances rn. I don’t know. I should go cuz I’ve been avoiding people like the plague and not wanting to leave the house, yet I’m going crazy here and I want to leave but I don’t want anyone to see me. It’s insane.
    But really, it’s a simple decision: yes or no? And I can’t make it!!! It’s driving me crazy. :/

  14. Brent says:

    Thank you for writing and sharing this. You hit the head on the nail with this:

    “Depression brings the whole world inside me. I look at people and everything around me, and I’m not seeing anything but evidence of how bad I am. I’m dancing with my own nightmares. Even if I’m only mildly depressed and feel suspended amid a thousand possibilities, no one of which I can choose, I’m assuming that whichever I might pick will not take me anywhere. I’ll move in an endless circle.”

  15. Helen says:

    Life Decision

    I have a huge life decision to make. I have been seeing my boyfriend for a year and a half . We live 3 hours and a 2 hour ferry ride from each other and in different countries. We spend only 2 weekends a month together and once in a while a week. We are excellent for each other, the same age, enjoy each others’ sense of humour and are very interested in conversations and love spending time together. He wants to get married and move here where he would easily find a job. I deathly afraid that once together, I will change my mind. Then here is something else . My sister and her husband are selling their beautiful condo for a cheap price. I love it . It’s near the river and running trails and I can have a my dog there. I know it sounds silly. House versus ever lasting love.

    My therapist said spend a summer with him and see. I guess I have to give up the condo but I’ve been doubting my wanting to be with him since shortly after starting to seeing him yet I love being with him. That, I don’t understand. I wonder if I should just walk away from the relationship if that comes to mind . But then I take an anti anxiety pill and I’m fine. I was all for buying the condo today and then after taking a few days’ break from my boyfriend, I was depressed and phoned him and felt good again. I am also so prone to other peoples’ judgement. I pick up vibes. He is super nice but a little different. He will be over nice sometimes, that kind of thing. Also he is very knowledgeable and over shares what he knows on topics. Hmmm, is that what drives me and others away; insecurity. I was drawn to my ex husband for his confidence but he turned out to be so confident that he thought he was always right and I everything that went wrong in the house was my fault (27 years of this) . Help!!!

  16. David Janus says:

    Hello John Folk-Williams (OP)

    Your article/post/blog etc has very powerful insights, and well written. Thank you so much. When you are depressed, never forget the power you have to help other people. You have helped me at a critical time when I’m very desperate and looking for some ray of light out of the darkness.

    You have given me that. Thank you. You probably saved a life.

  17. Daniel says:

    Its not easy to see yourself when depressed but to know yourself and understand your daily pattern of living is more important.

  18. sew it seams says:

    Thank you for sharing so boldly and honestly…this is EXACTLY how it is. If I’m not on medication, life overwhelms me to the point that I can’t move. On meds, I’m numb and want to cut all ties to everything and seem capable of making decisions which are nothing but bad for me and painful for others. Hoping this will get better with time and as I learn coping strategies, but it’s so hard to let others in when it’s all so…intense. So…all or nothing.

  19. guru says:

    hi everyone,

    i am having problem in making decisions, for example if i am working on one thing, suddenly some one tells about some thing new then my mind will get attracted to it and i cannot concentrate on the work i am doing. because of this i am confused which one is my goal. and in which field i want to start my career. so can anyone help me how to decide which one is my goal….

  20. Fred says:

    I’m posting in order to subscribe to followup comments.

    I’m 12 years into my recovery process and treatment for depression. I envy people who have loved ones willing to wait for them; I was very young (22) when I had my meltdown, and my ex-fiancée did not wait for me. I had left her for someone else in a desperate attempt to stop my pain; by the time I was clear-minded enough to realize what I had done, my ex had started seeing someone else and hated me. I’m still struggling to figure out how I let that happen.

    Hoping says in an earlier post that you have to realize you’re depressed. I definitely didn’t. I felt like me; it turns out I’ve had dysthymia probably since birth, so the major depressive episode just felt like I was more intensely me, if that makes any sense. I didn’t realize that life wasn’t like that for everyone. Every decision I made felt like a life or death matter that had to be dealt with immediately. I feel like I’ll never stop paying ythe price.


    • Hoping says:

      Hello Fred, I was one of them people who was willing to wait for my depressed Ex, She left me for another man in her desperate attempt to stop her pain. Waiting it hard when you know the one you love is ill and they dont!..and the damage they do can be bad. We in the end have to move on to protect our hearts. Like most of us here we fight that battle hopelessly trying to get the people we love to see they aren’t themselves and we all fail. I dont hate my ex i love her dearly always will, but i will never forget how worthless she made me feel. And i hope she finds the courage to find hersefls again. And im sorry you to had to suffer from this awful illness.

      • Fred says:

        Hoping, thank you for your response, and thank you for trying to hold on. I think my former fiancée would have waited longer, but her parents were very much involved in her life and I believe tbey manipulated her via finances to give up on me. She was still financially dependent on them, so they had a trump card. That in no way alleviates my guilt.

        I wish she had known I was sick. I really do think she simply thought of me as an asshole who had wasted five years of her life. I loved her, desperately so, but my sickness made her feel a million miles away. When she repeated that her parents said I was “dragging her down with me”, it was over for me. They confirmed my worst fears.

        I wish her a happy life filled with love, but I wish it had been with me, or at least that we could have parted on happier terms.

        • Hoping says:

          Whats so hard when your trying to hold on is that from the outside it can look like a normal break up, but its far from it..your blind sided when someone with depression ends things. And it takes a long to to feel normal again. I know my ex lost her connection to me..but she turned on me was cold and indifferent. Now im not sure if i want to every see that stranger again. How long did it take you to become clear? And did you see everything for how it really was? Or was it still a skewed version of you reality? Again im sorry this illness ruins good things.

    • Mas says:

      Hi Fred, I’ve spent the last year in limbo waiting for my husband to realise he has depression (or some other illness). After 15 years together he suddenly ended our marriage and asked me to leave. We were so happy together and close and it came completely out of the blue (after he’d been in a very stressful job). It’s like he’s a different person now. Everything I read about depression fits with his behaviour, but I took him to a psychologist and doctor and neither diagnosed him. They said he’s going through something but he is not opening up about his real feelings and that until he’s ready to open up there’s nothing they can do. Only six months after he asked me to leave, he started seeing someone else. Everyone is telling me to move on. But I know the man I married, I know he is a good person and that his behaviour is a result of depression. He has expressed sadness, worthlessness over and over again to me but not to anyone else. So I know the right thing to do is to wait. But how long for? Fred, I’m interested to hear how you felt and any insights you can offer.

      • Fred says:


        My answer has probably changed dramatically from what it would have been a year ago. My significant other of 5 years walked out on me in August, saying that my depression was too much for her handle. I think there were issues of her own that were more responsible, but I’ll likely never know.

        The biggest factor in my change of perspective was reading Healing the Shame That Binds You by John Bradshaw. I’m an atheist and had to struggle through parts of the book when Bradshaw evangelized or bore witness, but the vast majority of the book was earth shattering for me. I’d been eating myself alive with guilt for 13 years over the way I cheated on and left my fiancée, and finally I’m able to understand and forgive myself.

        At the time I was consumed with shame and felt that I didn’t measure up, a feeling that I now realize was ingrained in me from childhood. I have a much better understanding of not only why I am who I am and why I did what I did, but why my parents did as well. I went through a period of hating my parents for putting me through such turmoil, and the book allowed me to forgive.

        There’s a quote from the book Mirror Dance by Lois McMaster Bujold that I often read and think over: “I do think, half of what we call madness is just some poor slob dealing with pain by a strategy that annoys the people around him.”

        Obviously you’re in immense pain rather than annoyed, but the book by Bradshaw and the quote by Bujold point in the same direction: your husband is in immense pain, and in my perspective is looking for a cure in the form of another person, something that he will never find.
        I can’t answer how long to wait. It took me 36 years to find the Bradshaw book, after 13 years of acute suffering. I had to learn the hard way that the problem was in me, not in my surroundings or in my partner. Your husband might have to do the same, I don’t know. I wish I could give you a better answer, or any answer at all, really, but I can’t. I offer you my sympathy and thoughts and hopes that you can find your way out of your pain.

        You can’t fix him. You can’t force him to fix himself. There’s likely no words you can say that will make him see the light. Until he sees and accepts that he’s sick, his healing can’t even begin.


        • Mas says:

          Fred, thank you so much for your reply. Everything I’ve gone through over the past year confirms the truth of what you say. He has to come to a realisation on his own. If I can trouble you further for some insight on how you felt when you left your fiancée and what you felt with the new person.

          I guess I’m trying to understand this – my husband said he doesn’t love me anymore and I said ‘it feels like you don’t love anyone right now’. He agreed and said only his mum, who passed away 12 years before (she suffered from schizophrenia and committed suicide). I can understand how depression makes you not feel love. But then when he started a new relationship (with a much older lady, a colleague who was working with him at the time) I wondered how he could feel those feelings towards someone else. Maybe not love, but attraction etc. He went away on an overseas holiday with her, sharing a room. This was only a short time after they got together. When a friend questioned him about his new relationship, he’d said this lady is very active, goes hiking, socialising etc. All things he was down on himself about (he said he’s a slob, he’s too fat, watches too much tv). So I wondered if she represents something he’s aspiring to be.

          But I thought depression takes away your sex drive, your motivation to do things. How is a depressed person able to do all the things associated with dating? I suppose I’m trying to gain insights in to how he must be feeling so that I can be there to support him when he hits a low. We’ve been together since we were 20 (35 now) and have had the most loving relationship, we share values etc too. I can’t walk away from him when I know he is going through something. I remember the person he was and I love that person intensely. Now he is selfish, inward looking. I get that that is part of the illness. But I want to understand more about how a depressed person can seem to be enjoying life, and how they really feel inside. Thank you in advance!

          • Fred says:


            Sorry for the delay in responding – I’ve had a pretty bad week.

            At the time I felt like I was drowning. My first attempt to feel better was to drop out of graduate school after about a month and a half, and for a little while I did feel relieved. And then the panic returned. Well, if the problem wasn’t grad school, it must be the person I was in a relationship with. The woman I left for was about as big a mess as I was, so I felt needed, like she needed to be rescued. Thanks to my upbringing in a dysfunctional home, I’m a codependent. I thrive on being needed,and the other woman seemed to need me, whereas my fiancée didn’t. I felt like a complete failure, so feeling needed was a bright spot for me.

            I didn’t understand codependency at the time and I’ve only recognized it’s significance in my life and been seeking recovery since my partner walked out on me. As I said before, unrecognized shame has controlled my life, and I’ve always looked to other people to complete me or to make me feel okay. I now realize I left my fiancée because she wasn’t providing me with what I needed, but the thing is, no one could have. My codependency led me to believe that finding the right person would fix me. I now know better.

            Have you ever seen the movie The Prestige? Depression makes me feel like a completely different person from day to day. Take my former partner for instance: on a good day I was filled with love for her and could feel it. On a bad day I was in such pain that although I intellectually knew I loved her, I couldn’t feel it. That was one of the few good things to come out of my earlier experience: that just because I couldn’t feel the love at that moment didn’t mean it wasn’t there.

            Thank you for your sympathy. I struggle to understand that my partner had her own issues, but damn it, I would have loved to have been of assistance to her, but she doesn’t like showing vulnerability to anyone, not even to someone she was supposedly going to spend her life with. My therapist also says that the right person wouldn’t leave because of my depression, but of course my depression prevents me from believing her, especially given that my biggest supporter went from supporting and loving me one day to not being in love with me the next (I realize nothing happens that quickly, but that’s how it seemed to me – she didn’t clue me in on what she was going through).

        • Mas says:

          Sorry Fred, I wanted to add, I’m really sorry about what you’re going through with your partner leaving you. Five years is a long time. With no understanding of depression, I have the perhaps naive view that the right person can understand you and share your life. I take hope from what John on this website writes about, how his marriage survives. Thank you for sharing your thoughts even though you’re going through something difficult yourself.

          • Mas says:

            Hi Fred,

            Thanks so much for sharing what you went through. It is heartening to hear that you’ve come to understand some of the things that’s causing your pain. I’m sure it doesn’t always help but it would be so good to have some clarity. I’ve talked to my husband a great deal about depression and that I really think he’s going through something like that. But he keeps saying he’s fine and that he’s ‘not sad’. He has changed everything in his life and is trying to find happiness. I feel like I need to leave it alone for a little while and let him realise that the pain or flatness is coming from within and that changing his life will not help. But maybe it will help for a little while. And meanwhile I’m in limbo! And maybe he will never realise. It’s such a horrible situation.

  21. Rachel says:

    Whoever is reading this, I’m sure for most people it is a desperate hope to find an answer to what you are going through. I think this description of depression is the best I have found. I myself this morning was trapped in my own mind, which lead me here. These thoughts I describe are what I have decided may improve my life after reading this page.

    The biggest thing that has gone wrong is not the actual things that went wrong, although they were horrible to adjust to, but the loss of the ability to find happiness, hope and meaning. Or perhaps the ability to accept that what you do may no longer have a great deal of meaning, (for example your day job – or trying to find one if you are unemployed) but that is how your life is and when there is no practical alternative to try to believe that it is ok and that you need to be ok with yourself doing what seems like un-meaningful tasks.

    When you have no cause, it is very easy for people to try to help by telling you to find one. Of course there are many causes you would like to feel you believe in but maybe you aren’t quite attached to one yet in order for it to make a difference to how you value your life. Whether it be a faith, charity, person you love or passion (this is quite rare to find in a depressed state) I think the problem is that I don’t believe it will find you. Somehow you have to find it, even if you can’t physically go out perhaps you could find it in a book, on TV, online, another person you have contact with. Then you have to make contact with that cause – do something to feel part of it, whether it’s just a phone call, a letter or something more practical. After having a major passion and losing it through a series of bad events it makes sense for me to try to find a few little causes rather than one big one – without over complicating my life in a way that I can’t deal with when anxiety attacks or spreading my time between so many things that I have no sense of belonging. For some people it might be better to find just one cause, or sometimes I think it might be better for me to find a new one cause realising that if that one becomes difficult I will find another one. Everyone’s cause is different – but it should be your own, and not somebody else’s. You may be alone in your own mind, but you may not always be if you can let something else in.

    I hope this works. I’m off to find a cause for myself. Thanks to all the lovely people that have posted on this page.

  22. Kim says:

    First: Thank you John for setting up this page.

    I have been writing earlier on (below) about indecision due to depression during stressful situations. Reading through this page once again helps to remind me how bad off I was just a year ago.

    My summarization below is intended to point out some of the key aspects that have helped to redirect at least one “storied mind” back to his true and usual self. Perhaps these pointers may give some good insights of how to throw out the demon of depression hiding deep inside.

    The importance of moving on – I used to be stuck “in my bed, too immobilized to eat or even go to the bathroom”. It is very important to find a way to get the momentum back in life. To start thinking ahead rather than looking back. As painful or useless as it may seem to try moving on it will still have the reward of having taken action in it. And taking action means regaining control. Do not be afraid to ask for help to get a move on. Total entrapment in unsolvable situations or unmanageable circumstances is the slow strangling killer when facing a major depression.

    The importance of realignment – I used to “hesitate to make decisions because I’m afraid they will be wrong”. Clearly and without a doubt all important decision making while being depressed should be avoided. My experience with indecision is that life will graciously always give you more opportunities that will be there for you (yet again) when you are more ready to grab them. Realignment also has a great deal to do with changing life style, present life circumstances and/ or expectations on life. It is easier to find a daily sense of gratefulness when easing up on the goals and achievements.

    The importance of others – I used to feel “isolated, imprisoned in my apartment”. Let’s just face it. If heading into major depression it is vital to have others to rely on for support (not for decision making but for the sake of recovery). I do not believe there are many people that manage to “shape up” on own without the help of a supporting friend or relative. Isolation leads to entrapment and the best way then is to avoid remaining isolated. One obvious step to help break the spell of isolation is to understand that you are not alone and that there is help to find.

    The importance of faith – I used to feel completely lost and helpless. Somehow I cannot help but stressing how important it is to be able to find true faith in God. From then on you will always be heading somewhere, whatever achievements or failures in life that you struggle with are suddenly of minor importance, and you will never ever have to be alone again. Depression always seems to arise from losing faith in oneself. My point here is that lasting faith may actually be found elsewhere.

    As far as I know the only really important decision I had to make while being depressed was to “never give up”. And that was not even much of a decision.


  23. Alan says:

    I have to say this is the best explanation of feeling depressed that I’ve ever read. I couldn’t have put it better myself, I even recently penetrated the ‘saying NO to ending it all’ barrier, but It doesn’t get get much easier, in fact i don’t have the ‘ending it all’ crutch to lean on any more, I have to do this the hard way.

    For those that have never experienced severe depression, this is what it’s truly like, your doctor is unlikely to understand to the extent this author does, and indeed the British NHS service understood depression so badly that it only drove me closer to ending it all when I was at my worst.

    My advice; seek to understand your mind yourself, and try your best to love those around you, that will keep the hope if a better life alive. Also, confront your demons, it will seem impossible at first but once you take the first step it can only get better. (in my case i had to confront my father about childhood emotional issues)

    Despite how you might feel there are understanding people out there but don’t be fooled there are a lot of uneducated people who cannot and will not understand your condition, avoid them if you must and seek out those who are a little more emotionally sensitive.

  24. Hoping says:

    This is helpful to know, but only if your aware your depressed. My ex partner broke up with me afew months ago yet she’s depressed but in denial of it obviously not aware of it at all. It’s her reality how do I question her reality against my own?

  25. may says:

    really i learn alot from all of you.iam so sorry for that and i am now in the same situation since 20 day my boyfriend he broke up with and go away.but my question please if the dispressed pesron not come back why they have to go doctors and take medicine i was hopping he will back when he is will be ok and good?

  26. oxy says:

    this is my biggest problem i ever had in my entire life.. i cant make up my mind on the right time and most difficult part of my life is when i didn’t make up my mind on time realize me that i made a mistake which make me very upset , disappointed n very sad…if you guy’s know what can i do for rid off from this situation plz plz plz tell me i really need inspiration…

    • Donna-1 says:

      Yeah, this can be a big problem. I deal with the same issue. I think depression makes me more sensitive to failure, so I hesitate to make decisions because I’m afraid they will be wrong. Part of the problem is, there isn’t always a lot of time to make the decision (whatever it is). So by the time I weigh all the positives and negatives and possible consequences, the optimum moment for deciding has already passed, and often it is just plain too late. I’ve missed an opportunity. I’ve lost out on something good, or I’ve lost a chance to experience something fun, or people have moved on in their lives and left me behind. Sometimes, you just have to make a leap of faith and go with your gut instinct and hope for the best. If you get too bogged down in what you “should” or “could” or “ought” to do, that can actually just become a way of avoiding the responsibility of making a decision. You wait too late and then you don’t have to decide. Then you get mad at yourself for NOT taking the leap and it just makes you more depressed. Or at least this is what happens to me. It is one of those vicious cycles. Damned if you do, damned if you don’t. But if you go ahead and make your move, even if you fail you will know you tried your best.

  27. Brittany says:

    This is my current downward spiral. It’s terrible..a terrible rut, “All the creative possibilities I might see when I’m healthy become so many triggers of obsessive thinking.” So, then I ignore everything till it builds so much that I’m waiting for something to crash and burn so I don’t have to do it myself. It’s like I want it to all end and go away so I have a way out and I can recuperate and start again fresh without all the obligatory sh*t in my life which drives my depression incessantly. bah.

    Thanks for the article..much of what you describe is how I feel 100% of the time. It sucks. My counselor called it “Turning a Corner” when I must make a decision to a path that I want to try…which is incredibly hard for me :(. The unknown is scary. I dunno, why I’m responding, just want to say, I relate to everything in the article and everyone’s responses.

  28. David says:

    Hi Jon,
    Great article, I too have hit rockbottom again in the space of 8 months and what you wrote above struck a massive cord with me. I hate the fact the depression I have effects me and family and this time has me questioning if still I love my partner anymore on top of my other issues. I don’t want to say anything or do anything yet until I’m in a better place, but I’m not sure I’ll ever get to a better place again.

    Though I don’t want to commit suicide if I had a heart attack today I would be a happy man.


  29. Jess says:

    In the past I too had a very difficult time making decisions when under a great deal of stress or anxiety. I found if I did force myself to make a decision, many times I would come to regret that decision later. Waiting until you are in a better place to make a decision, especially an important one, makes good sense. Thanks for posting!

    • mike says:

      I’m terrified of my situation that I feel is quickly getting worse. Severe depression due to long term unemployment, now broke, having to move out of my apartment and return to my conservative, small town to share a condo with my 91 yr old mother. At 54 and clueless about what I can do for employment I’m feeling panick, grief, shame, intense regrets but no choice left. My life feels ended. Doom and gloom surrounds me. Isolated, imprisoned in my apartment and beginning to fade awasy physically. I’ve had many depressions but was able to ride them out, now I have no choice but uprrot and relocate again, lost my house in the last 3 years so I’m spending time in any fashion to find comfort and distraction from the reality and torment I feel but can’t avoid the future choices. Many, many hours spent contemplating the utitmate solution but too frightened to lift a finger on that as well. Trapped and without hope, direction or sleep.

      • Jon says:

        You incapsulated the highly concentrated period of depression that may in fact be reflected in many who have survived the poisons of MDD for so long. OMG your list describing your mid life march through humiliation, loss and fear while suffering the constant burn of untreated depression was really spot on. Or I should say it resinated with me very much. I hold out hope and I wish you every opportunity for good and healing. Keep going, please… that’s what we do, right?

  30. Robyn says:

    I was searching the web to find an answer to my question, “why can’t I make a decision” and I found your post and read it and all the comments. We all seem to be in this black boat together, weathering a storm of anxiety, self doubt and indecision. I want to be part of life but I also want to cut myself off from everything. I lay in my bed, too imobilized to eat or even go to the bathroom.
    I am not sad or suicidal, I feel nothing. I start an interest and even though I want to continue I have no motivation to do so. The only things I do are things I must because the shame I would experience in the eyes of others would be too much to bear. Like another commenter, I also feel it is contrary to my actual nature. In the good times I am born leader. i will read more of your posts to try to find the answer mean’t for me. I like your style of writing, there is a kindness in it.

  31. KM says:

    I guess now’s not the time to decide to pursue some sort of permanent birth control…?

  32. Me says:

    I just reread this post and found new meaning. Fear of making decisions, procrastination, fear of failure remain with me . But somehow when all seems lost, I decide not to give up and decide to go on for another day.

    • Jeanie says:

      Yes you are right – giving up is suicide. And what’s the point of that. So yes I have once again raised myself up. There was something you wrote that has really stuck in my mind. We spend so much time “cursing” our depression and you said we must learn to live with it as part of who we are, not as if its a demon sitting on our shoulder (my words latter part!!). We need to take in into ourselves and really feel that it is part of our living composition, in our mind, flesh and bones. As with sleeping eating laughing crying, depression is part of the series, more some days and less others.
      I am trying to include it as part of me rather than an external force.
      Thank you John for your crisp clarity despite the mind-befuddling roaring and subsiding of depression.

    • Enigma says:

      I wonder for how long I can live this get by life,Sooner or later it will cease to be even an option and then that another day that I’ve been living will not come.Two choices are all I have–either get out of here or get out of life.I’ve already resisted making any decision for over a month,but this is killing me now.The sheer worthlessness of my being is weighing heavily on my conscience.Got,only days to decide now,but thoughts are so messed up that I can’t think clearly,if I choose life,i have to get out of here.

  33. Jeanie says:

    Hi John
    Just found your site. You speak to the heart with your talent for words. You have a gift. Can’t write much now – too detached. But want to say what happens when over and over and over again you make the decision to lift yourself up and for awhile life is moving at a nice, manageable pace.; but then down you go again and again and again.. until there is no strength anymore to get up, to crawl away from the darkness. You know you will only return once again so why bother. This has been my pattern for 20 years and I am just too tired now, too worn out.. and feeling guilty and ashamed to burden readers with my despair.

    • Jon says:

      As much as I wish us both renewed capacity to get up again and take our place in this amazing experiment, I totally understand the exhaustion you describe. I’d like to reach out and hold you up until you’re able again.
      peace and strength to you,

      • Jeanie Bailey says:

        Hi Jon
        You hold people up every day with your lucid and truthful words. I have read many web-pages on depression over the years and yours is the only one that reaches those dark pits where depression resides.

        You have helped me realise that deperssion is part of me and not outside me; it is not a dark force that descends; its a darkness that lives within. It can’t be descarded so it must be part of the journey that is life. With that in mind I have started an exercise regime that has buffered the darkness and my life at this moment is content. I am living in this moment.

        So Jon you have reached out and you have held me up so I can reach this moment. We can’t ask for more than this. I will be depressed one day again but not now.

        I hope others may reach the realisation that depression is part of us. We can’t curse it. We can’t wring our hands and say why me. It just is as it is. We all feel suicidal at some point. We all reach points of utter exhaustion. We all have times where even having a shower is beyond our ability. I say to myself thats OK. This is me. I am where I am. Someday ahead I will be able to shower and feel the other parts of me that make me whole. Love to you all.

  34. Laura says:

    Once, I was on the point of making a serious mistake. I wanted to break up with my boyfriend because I had accumulated too many details of his gestures, attitudes and behaviour towards a certain girl. I was so angry and so frustrated. I didn’t want to part with him because I really loved him. We have a five-year relationship. All I did was to cry and be indifferent to him, although he was acting normally, but I was so lucid and so rational. I was even searching for other reasons why I should leave him. I was also listening to sad music which made me feel even more horrible than I had felt. I think I was a sadist myself. I felt depressed for almost two weeks. He noticed that I wasn’t okay, and started asking me questions. I would avoid them. After so much pain my reaction would be to alienate from him. But I simply didn’t have the guts to leave him and tell him what I was thinking. Little by little, those thoughts left me, because I realised he was still loving me.
    Nevertheless, I am still predisposed to this kind of depression. Now I realise how much depression can change you if you allow it to do that. I felt as if I were a stranger myself. That pain needs a pause at some point, and you think that taking a decision at that very moment would change your life and be happy again. You have the impression that you’re right, but you are completely in the wrong. Maybe I am exposing myself to suffering and too much pain, but in the end I don’t have the courage to take up the responsibility of a wrong choice and I just leave it. Anyway, it is a dangerous method.
    Best regards.

  35. michele says:

    The two articles I read—the one about relationships and this one about decision making with depression really spoke to me. My husband decided just before our wedding that he wanted to move back home, which is overseas to Israel. I’ve always had the tendency toward depression, but as our departure came closer I was struck with a nasty bout of it. I saw a psychologist, marriage counselor, and began taking Zoloft just to be able to be alone in a room without the “what ifs” swarming in my head and tears swimming in my eyes.

    What’s strange is that I never felt like I decided to move– I could have called off the wedding, not filled out the paperwork, not packed up/sold my belongings, not boarded the plane, and I could have left at any time, but I never really decided–this is it, I’m going to live abroad, I’m going to make this work.

    Even though I logically know that postponing making a decision until I feel better is the best idea in my situation, waiting has its own set of “whatifs.” I’m constantly reminded that I’m already 30 and if I ever want to have a family…

    And I don’t even trust myself in my feelings about my husband. I’m currently so resentful of him (feeling like he forced me to move here, not accepting my hand in the decision), that I would be relieved to just go back to the U.S. But there’s no doubt that I would miss him, regret it…

    He is trying to be patient with me while I blurt out negative feelings, but he’s anchored his feet… he says he staying here no matter what I decide.

    • John Folk-Williams says:

      Hi, Michele –

      What a terribly difficult situation to be in when you’re depressed. I’m not sure if it would help you, but the method of focusing on what you most value rather than the reasons and what if scenarios might simplify making a decision. It’s the approach I describe in the latest post on Inner Beliefs vs Outer Action. The best motives for choosing are rooted in the things we value most deeply. This is something I’ve been learning from Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and is a broader view than the one I had in mind while writing this post on making decisions.

      My best to you —


  36. Vernell says:

    As a woman whose husband has been diagnosed with depression and who has now had him leave me with our 8 month old son for a new woman and life so unlike we built together, Im beginning to wonder if his decision to sell our house and divorce should be stalled until he is 100% well.

    His medication has been doubled for the last 2 weeks but he is still drinking heavily on them but seems clear headed and is adamant this is what he wants…He doesnt love me, wants out of our marriage and wishes to set up home with his new woman who also has mental health issues.

    Its so hard for me to know what is best to do as he is constantly telling me he doesnt love me and we need to sell up etc, but this has come out of the blue, and he is living a life all of the sudden that is so unlike him and is actually a life he would criticise others for leading.

  37. Daffa says:

    Thank you. I feel relieved I am not alone with the torture of making a decision under duress.

  38. Sriram says:

    Superb piece. What strategies does one follow to overcome this?

    • John Folk-Williams says:

      That’s a hard one to answer. Usually, I try to avoid any big decision when I’m depressed. At times I’ve tried a mechanical approach of listing out criteria, pro’s and con’s etc. The problem with that is that there is a crucial emotional component to every important decision. If it doesn’t feel right – despite all the rational reasons for doing it – you won’t want to follow that decision. When depressed, of course, I either feel nothing at all (so worrying about the decision seems pointless) or so despairing that every option seems miserable and hopeless. Not much fun.


      • Kim says:

        I also like this blog a lot and can relate strongly to almost each and every experience described on account of depression.

        I am presently having my second hurdle in life with regards to this immobilizing condition. It is a very much real and terrifying experience that somehow also feeds on itself and that practically makes me unable to sleep more than a few hours a night and makes me toss around in shivers/ shakes of anxiety.

        Right now I am stressed to make a crucial decision if I should go ahead and buy an apartment that has been booked for purchase andI have extreme difficulties in coming to a firm decision. The indecision makes me stay mindlocked rather than to be able to move on. Letting the deadline pass without having reached a clear decision is equal to an avalanche of despair and regret. Any decision made in time (yes/ no) cause immediate fear of having come to the right or the wrong decision and so I reevaluate again for a new decision.

        Since this is a flat that we will forcibly be locked down with for at least 5 years the emotional ingredient is very important – and as explained it is either non-existent or randomized. It is impossible for me to judge clearly from the present point of view and it is driving me insane. And time is running short.

        From where I am at right now I am not even sure if I can even make it to any appointments to even sign the papers if I go for ‘yes’. Indeed it may be very awkward.

        The ‘do-or-die’ in having to decide when you are really not well is deteriorating me as I cannot snap out thinking about of it – all of the time – and even if I am reasoning to let things be/ to let it go / I bounce right back into the decision making thought process sooner or later. When in this kind of mental condition everything becomes a trap. There are no solutions and it is easy to spark off other negative evaluations.

        Thus from my present point of view I find it downright dangerous to have to make major decisions when heading for a more severe depression since it will always come out random or not at all in the end because of the emotional turmoil/ or blankness, the confusion and physical exhaustion. But what if you must choose and are in a hurry to do it (we are talking about hundreds of thousands of $ paid for someone that is not rich)?


        • John Folk-Williams says:

          Hi, Kim –

          You convey the anguish all too well, and I’ve been trapped in that do-or-die decision mode too many times. In the situation you describe, it sounds like there is no option not to decide – is there? Letting the deadline pass is the same as saying no?? What I’ve been training myself to do is to just face the fear and walk through it. The fear by itself is only that, and I find that the real-world consequences are never as terrible as the anguish and panic – or the intense shame of not deciding. It sounds too rational and pat as I write that down, but in a way the fear is the problem I’m facing, not the decision. And I’ve let fear run my life for too long. Maybe it takes a certain amount of fear-bred disaster to get to the point I’m at now. I’m sorry it’s so impossible for you, and I hope you’ve been finding something to guide you through.


          • kim says:

            Thank you for your reply. I am in dire need of encouragement.

            Just want to share on what happened after the deadline expired. Shed some light on it for others to read…

            I cowardly let my wife steer our steps, reasoning that she would see things clearer than me. I believe that she did choose my health over finanical gains and status. Thus I feel like I did not give her any choice. From that moment on it had to become a sacrificed opportunity, a “no”.

            For me things are now in a shutdown, motivation lost, no future perspectives, self pity. Depression is still there but the acute anxiety is gone leaving room for apathy. I admit serious regrets for not facing my fears. For not being decisive. For abandoning my post in the midst of battle.

            Today my therapist ask ‘so what has changed?’. I reply ‘nothing’. My wife says ‘everything’. Feel like still stuck in a hole unable to see anything else but rainy clouds far above. She is already a bird in the sky.

            It is impossible to know what would have turned out better or worse, but it seems at least that even if ‘no’ in this case was a bad decision we do continue to live in the present and I am to some degree relieved and did not force change upon myself (and others) at a time most vulnerable.

            The spell of depression is not broken and confidence is at an all time low. But life goes on regardless. No one died. No one was injured. Cash still in the bank, even if the heart is poor.

            If anything, through this ordeal, it has brought me closer to God.

  39. Donna-1 says:

    Many days (they flow into each other) I wander from what absolutely must be done, like laundry, to absolute immobility, like lying in bed. The time spent in bed might even be worth something if I could sleep. But I can’t. I’m either trying desperately to keep from thinking, or I’m obsessing about conversations I want to have with other people but never will. Often, these “mental conversations” end darkly. I am almost seduced by the pleasurable fantasy of “disappearing,” as you say. And there are many ways to disappear besides suicide — holing up in my apartment and refusing to answer the phone; packing up my stuff and moving to Arizona; refusal to visit any of my usual haunts and therefore setting myself up to be forgotten, and even delivering myself over to a punishing diet and exercise wellness routine. Some people disappear into books, some into gambling, some into drugs. There’s a whole smorgasbord to choose from.

    I’m afraid to interact with people and society, but what happens if I “disappear?” Would I be any happier or would it just be more bed-time obsessing?

    • John Folk-Williams says:

      Hi, Donna –

      It’s so good to hear from you again! It sounds like you’ve had a hard time recently, and I hope you’re feeling better. I must say as a veteran of disappearing that I wouldn’t recommend it. Sometimes, it is sooo tempting, like a beckoning paradise of simplicity and contentment. But I’ve always found it to be a dangerous Siren song that only leads me into more pain – and shame.


  40. Dear John,
    Terrific piece. Yes, I know how difficult it is to make decisions during a depression. In some cases, I learned that I was better off not making them because my judgment was impaired.

    In other cases, I couldn’t seem to make a decision no matter how hard I tried. And perhaps some of that was because I had become terribly confused about what I wanted or thought I wanted.

    What’s interesting to me is that an inability to make a decision is contrary to my nature when I’m well. One of my best skills is my analytical ability, and I like making decisions. So…it was always so disturbing to be so wishy-washy.


    • john says:

      Thank you! I know well what you mean about acting against your nature when depressed. I have endless experiences with that, all of them things I wish I could just forget.

      Holding off from deciding sounds exactly right. Trying when you have half a brain to work with only adds to the torment.

      All my best to you —


  41. Wendy Love says:

    Here is another article on decision making and depression which may shine some more light

    • john says:

      Wendy –

      I finally had a chance to look at the article you mention. People had to make choices under (mild) stress and went with the safer one, associated with smiling faces. That makes sense – though that sort of stress – momentary distraction while trying to make the choice – doesn’t capture the sustained impact of depression. Retreating to safe ground when the mind isn’t free to do its work sounds like a good strategy.

      Thanks for the reference.


  42. Ellen says:

    Hi John,
    I um ‘suck’ at making decisions. Recently I was trying to decide on a therapy method and therapist, and ended up just going with whatever was closest to hand. Not the best way.

    However, I also found that sometimes I would try to hedge my discomfort with decisions by doing a lot of research – for me, research can lead to endless detours and procrastination and in the end, I would still have to make a decision. I spent about two years trying to decide on a brand of car – in the end, I just went with a Honda because I’d had one before and liked it. A lot of research and agonizing wasted really.

    Now what I’m trying to do more is to discern what I really want – what is it I really like, emotionally? That’s kind of a small voice inside, not so easy for me to hear. But that way, at least I choose something I genuinely desire, whether in the end it was the best choice or not. Kind of trying to respect my own personality.

    Now, what do I really want for dinner, truly? Perhaps pasta…with something green. Yes, that will make my heart glad!


    • john says:

      Hi, Ellen –

      That sounds so familiar – two years for a car is impressive. Of course, you don’t want to rush into anything. I’m busy at every procrastination sale and always come home laden with bargains.

      But you’re so right, you have to get clear about what you want. If only that were a simple thing to do! It’s embarrassing how long it takes me to figure out what I’m really trying to say in these posts. At least I’m able to keep asking that question and staying with it until I’ve cleared away all the digressions. But it takes way too much time, given all the other things I’m trying to do.

      I like that idea of respecting your own personality. Perhaps that’s a key part of this inability to decide – not accepting the legitimacy of your own wants and desires but trying to import them from somewhere else – like research into what other people think you should want.

      Best of luck – I hope you enjoyed that dinner.


  43. Louise says:

    I am finding your blog most helpful and enjoyable; and, I agree, you have a great writing style!

    I wish to share a book that caused a shift for me: Mystic Path to Cosmic Power by Vernon Howard (or any work by Vernon Howard). Yes, it’s a corny title, but it contains authentic answers to worry, heartache, and suffering.

    An excerpt: “We must see what happiness is not. It is not exterior activity; that is merely a distraction from inner unhappiness. What, then, is happiness? The answer is not complex. Happiness is simply a state of inner freedom. Freedom from what? With a bit of self-insight, every individual can ancer that question for himself. It is freedom from the secret angers and anxieties we tell no one about. It is freedom from fear of being unappreciated and ignored, from muddled thinking that drives us to compulsive actions, and later, to regrets. It is freedom from painful cravings that deceive us into thinking that our attainment of this person or of that circumstance will make every right. Happiness is liberty from everything that makes us unhappy….it is formless; it cannot be fitted into the frame of our demands. We insist upon this wife or husband, this career or achievement, this home, this secrity, excitement, or distraction. Even if we get our demand, we are no happier than before; we have merely covered our unhappiness. It is still there, and it will inevitably show itself when change occurs. We must break the frame altogether, and just let life happen; then, we enter an amazing new world whose existence we never before suspected.”

    “For a happy life is joy in the truth.” (Augustine)

    • john says:

      Hello, Louise –

      That is a beautiful passage. It’s amazing how many writers I keep discovering who’ve been around for a long time and have inspired millions.

      Thank you for letting me know about his work and also for your kind words about the blog.

      All my best —


  44. Wendy Love says:

    This is so good, so well-written and so true! The way you break down the process of thinking and deciding and ruminating etc. impresses me. I tend to be a bottomline kind of writer and your details add so much. I decide when I am well, then regret when I am not well. One way or the other, it is a difficult process. I used to be very decisive and so being undecisive is a change which I have not yet adjusted to. Thanks for the challenging ideas.

    • john says:

      Thanks, Wendy –

      You’re too kind! It interests me that you changed from being very decisive. I went through perhaps a similar shift at midlife as measured by Meyers Briggs. From being a very cocksure and decisive INTJ to an INFP – much less interested in reaching sharp conclusions as in exploring possibilities – often for far too long to get things done.

      Thanks for your comment.



  1. […] this one (Making Decisions When Depressed), John describes what it is like to make decisions while in the different levels of depression. He […]

  2. […] I just came upon this post fromJohn at themental health blog Storied Mind about making decisions whe…. I love his description: […]

By clicking the Submit button below you agree to follow the Commenting Guidelines